Last Wednesday, December 2, 2009, the Third District Court of Appeal denied the State of Florida's Motions for Rehearing & Conflict Certification in the "condemnation blight" case, Florida DEP v. West, et al. (original opinion affirming trial court), Case No. 3D08-3185. Two days later, on December 4, 2009, the State's trial/appellate counsel asked us to pick a date in January for the State to write the checks in this case.
This suggests the State decided not to seek discretionary review from the Florida Supreme Court -- a wiser decision than their last one in Collins v. Monroe County & the State of Florida. But, in Collins, the State and County did not face the prospect of incurring almost $2,000 per day in interest costs, so they could waste the landowners' time and money at will.
For those considering a "condemnation blight" attack on value-reducing land development regulations, consider the following. The State deposited $550,000 for Parcel 1 and $80,000 for Parcel 7, as its "good faith" fair market value estimates, in April 2004. The 2008 jury verdicts were $5,060,000 (Parcel 1) and $450,000 (Parcel 7) -- based on the April 2004 real estate market. These verdicts were 9.2 times (820% over) and 5.625 times (462.5% over) the 2004 "good-faith" estimates.
The October 8, 2008, judgments included interest from 2004, bringing the just compensation values to $6,908,114 and $599,142, respectively, or $7,507,256. Presuming the case can be resolved by January 15, 2010, the State's appeal will add $682,398 in additional interest to the landowners' awards -- bringing their compensation up to $8,189,654, or 13 times the State's 2004 "good-faith" estimates (or, if you like your numbers inverted, the good-faith estimates were only 7.7% of the condemnation award, with interest).
